"Should I hire a private DUI attorney, or go with a public defender?"

Posted by Daniel J. Gerl | Mar 09, 2013 | 0 Comments

I'm often asked by a prospective client charged with a Seattle or Tacoma DUI (or other criminal matter), or posed via Avvo, whether they should hire their own attorney or "go with a public defender (PD)." My answer is simple - that "choice" should already be determined.

Public defender

Our Constitution guarantees those accused with a crime the right to counsel. If you cannot afford an attorney then you will be provided one (on the taxpayers' dime of course). If you can afford one, however, then you have to either hire one or go it alone (which is of course ill-advised). I don't know about others but I will never say anything bad about public defenders. I have been on public defender conflict panels in the past, and continue to take on a conflict case on occasion. I fought just as hard for those clients as I do those who retained me privately. Most PDs I know are dedicated attorneys who fight hard for their clients. I also know some who I would not wish on my worse enemy. I'd say the same about private defense attorneys.

One practical reality is caseload. Public defenders generally have caseloads many times greater than private attorneys. While a person has complete control over which private attorney they hire, he has no control over which PD is assigned to his case (or even appears at a given court hearing). PDs generally do not handle civil matters associated with the criminal charge - Department of Licensing (DOL) hearings, for instance, or civil Protection Order matters in other courts.

So when it comes to representation, the "choice" really isn't whether to go with a public defender or hire an attorney. If you can afford an attorney on your own, or have access to resources that would allow you to, then you should - after exhaustive research (Avvo is a great resource for this). If not, the court will appoint a public defender and you will most likely be in good hands.

About the Author

Daniel J. Gerl

Dan Gerl is a former prosecutor with over ten years of experience handling DUI, criminal and traffic cases throughout Western Washington. Dan handled hundreds of traffic infractions, avoiding negative impact on driving records over 98% of the time . If you are cited with a traffic or speeding infraction, and you want to keep your record clean, Puget Law Group is your best defense!


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment


IN TACOMA: 708 Broadway, Suite 400 Tacoma, WA 98402
TEL: 253 627 4696 | FAX: 253 617 1013

IN OLYMPIA: 400 Union Ave SE, Suite 200 Olympia, WA 98501
TEL: 253 627 4696 | FAX: 253 617 1013

Disclaimer: No information presented within the pages of this website should not be considered formal legal advice or the formation of a priviledged lawyer/attorney-client relationship. Please contact an attorney to discuss your specific legal matter. © 2014 Gerl Law PLLC. All rights reserved.